Best Horror Movies to Watch on Hulu This September 2025

Why Hulu Horror Hits Different in 2025

September marks the gateway to spooky season, and Hulu is delivering the chills early. With a mix of cult classics, psychological thrillers, and brand-new releases, the platform is a goldmine for horror fans this month.

Here’s our curated list of must-watch horror movies on Hulu this September 2025.

Top Horror Picks on Hulu – September 2025

1. The Boogeyman’s Return (2025)

A chilling sequel that expands on last year’s breakout horror hit. This time, the shadows aren’t just in the closet—they’re everywhere.

✅ Why Watch: Fresh release, tense atmosphere, and social media buzz.

2. Hereditary (2018)

A modern masterpiece of psychological horror, where family trauma turns into something darker and supernatural.

✅ Why Watch: Perfect rewatch for fans of slow-burn terror.

3. A Quiet Place II (2021)

The terrifying sequel that turns silence into survival. An edge-of-your-seat watch for horror + sci-fi fans alike.

✅ Why Watch: Still trending with monster-thriller lovers.

4. The Nun II (2023)

Part of The Conjuring universe, this film dives deeper into the origins of the demon Valak.

✅ Why Watch: Gothic settings + jump scares = perfect spooky vibes.

5. Fresh (2022)

Not your typical horror flick—this satirical thriller about dating gone horribly wrong is both stylish and disturbing.

✅ Why Watch: Dark humor blended with bloody horror makes it stand out.

6. No One Will Save You (2023)

An alien invasion thriller with almost no dialogue, but loaded with atmosphere and shocks.

✅ Why Watch: Unique storytelling, terrifying execution.

7. The Boogeyman (2023)

Stephen King adaptations rarely disappoint, and this one delivers creepy shadows and emotional depth.

✅ Why Watch: Short, scary, and based on King’s chilling short story.

Tips for the Perfect Spooky Watch

Dim the lights (candles if you dare 🔥)
Use headphones or a soundbar for maximum jump-scare effect
Watch late at night for true horror vibes

FAQ: Hulu Horror Movies September 2025

What’s new on Hulu horror this September 2025?

The Boogeyman’s Return (2025) is the big new drop, alongside classics rotating back into the catalog.

Are Hulu horror movies available outside the US?

Most titles are region-locked, but VPNs or Hulu partnerships (like Disney+ Star) may offer access abroad.

Which movie is the scariest on the list?

Hereditary and The Nun II are top choices for bone-chilling horror.

Final Thoughts

Whether you’re into demonic thrillers, alien terror, or psychological nightmares, Hulu’s September 2025 lineup has something for every horror fan. Start spooky season early with these must-watch titles, and don’t forget to share your favorites with fellow fans.

Top Horror Movies You Must Watch in 2025